The Daley Note

Ghost of Keystone Could Haunt South Bow, Bridger Pipe Proposal

Crude, Enbridge, Phillips 66, South Bow, The Daley Note, WCSB

Posted by:

Bridger Pipeline and South Bow (SOBO) reportedly plan to develop a new pipeline to move Canadian crude oil from Guernsey, WY to the Cushing hub in Oklahoma. The ambitious project will lean on remnants of the former Keystone XL, and could face similar scrutiny as that proposal.

Reuters reports that Bridger and SOBO have formed a joint venture to acquire the right-of-way of the former Liberty Oil Pipeline from Tallgrass Energy. Liberty was originally proposed in 2019 by Phillips 66 (PSX) and Bridger as a Guernsey-to-Cushing crude pipeline. The project had long-term shipper commitments, but PSX withdrew it in 2021 amid the post-Covid industry retrenchment.

The new Cushing-bound pipeline would connect to Bridger Pipeline’s proposed expansion from the US-Canada border to Guernsey, a roughly 650-mile, 36-inch pipeline designed to transport up to 550 Mb/d of Canadian crude. That project in turn would connect to SOBO’s proposed Prairie Connector pipeline, moving up to 550 Mb/d of Canadian barrels from Hardisty, Alberta, to the US-Canada border.

Prairie Connector would use some of the pipeline built for Keystone XL before it was ultimately abandoned. After securing 20-year binding shipper commitments in May, South Bow continues to target a final investment decision (FID) for Prairie Connector next year. Together, the three projects represent a joint effort by Bridger and SOBO to establish a new crude corridor from Canada to Cushing, enabling barrels to then reach downstream Gulf Coast markets.

The proposals come at a critical time for Canadian crude egress. East Daley’s Crude Hub Model forecasts Canadian crude production will grow 4.2% through 2031 and steadily fill pipeline capacity. Many projects to address short-term production growth are nearing or have already reached FID, such as Enbridge’s (ENB) 30 Mb/d Platte expansion, 400 Mb/d of Mainline expansions, and downstream plans to reverse Enbridge’s Bakken Pipeline to supply the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL). Prairie Connector would be the next major addition to Alberta’s export capacity, helping preserve destination flexibility as Canadian production continues to grow.

While SOBO has secured shipper commitments for Prairie Connector and Liberty’s former right-of-way provides a potential downstream corridor, the success of the broader system ultimately depends on Bridger’s proposed expansion through Montana and Wyoming. That segment has already encountered legal challenges during the permitting process.

When filing for a Certificate of Compliance with the Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), Bridger requested to omit certain financial and environmental information from its application. The DEQ granted the request, a decision that environmental organizations and affected landowners argue violates Montana law, since public notice was not provided and a hearing was not held.

Bridger’s attempt to withhold environmental information from public disclosure recalls the legal battles that slowed Keystone XL in Montana. In 2018, US District Judge Brian Morris halted Keystone XL construction after finding shortcomings in the federal environmental review, including its analysis of oil spill risks and other environmental impacts. The ruling became a major legal setback in Keystone XL’s permitting process, despite strong support from the Trump administration.

While Bridger’s project is not Keystone XL, the permitting process has entered a regulatory environment in Montana that has proven challenging for major cross-border crude pipelines. As a result, Bridger’s project could face the same legal scrutiny that defined Keystone XL’s prolonged permitting process. – Carter Ware Tickers: ENB, PSX, SOBO.

 

One Market, One Model: Gain a Holistic View of North America Supply & Demand 

East Daley Analytics is pleased to announce the Canada Supply & Demand report. The Canada S&D completes our North American model, providing a fully integrated supply and demand forecast for crude oil and natural gas. East Daley follows molecules from Canadian production through US infrastructure to end-markets. Clients now have a continental view to anticipate trends, from how Canadian gas is reshaping Midwest markets, to how crude imports flow to Gulf Coast refiners. The Canada S&D report and dataset is available exclusively in Energy Data StudioReach out to learn more about East Daley’s North American energy model.

 

The Daley Note

Subscribe to The Daley Note for energy insights delivered daily to your inbox. The Daley Note covers news, commodity prices, security prices and EDA research likely to affect markets in the short term.

SUBSCRIBE TO THE DALEY NOTE

Recent Posts